1. US Court Allows Pannun to Serve Lawsuit on Ajit Doval and Former RAW Chief Through Delhi Courts
The United States District Court for the Southern District of New York allowed Khalistani separatist Gurpatwant Singh Pannun to serve his civil lawsuit on National Security Advisor Ajit Doval and former RAW chief Samant Goel through Indian courts. Pannun has alleged that Doval, Goel and others were involved in a conspiracy to assassinate him on American soil because of his role in the Khalistan movement. The order permits service of the lawsuit through the specified procedure; it does not decide the truth of the allegations.
2. Possibility of Crime Alone Cannot Justify Restrictions on Licensed Bars: Kerala High Court
The Kerala High Court held that the police cannot restrict the operating hours of establishments holding valid FL-3 liquor licences merely because criminal activities may take place there. The Court observed that the possibility of crime, without sufficient supporting grounds, cannot justify restrictions under the Kerala Police Act on extended operating hours. The ruling clarifies that authorities must have proper justification before restricting the operation of licensed establishments.
3. BNS Provision on Outraging Modesty Applies to Transgender Women: Bombay High Court
The Nagpur Bench of the Bombay High Court held that transgender persons who identify as women can invoke the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita provision dealing with outraging the modesty of a woman. The Court also observed that a person can identify as transgender even without obtaining a certificate of identity. The ruling recognises the protection of transgender women under the relevant criminal law provision and clarifies that the absence of an identity certificate does not, by itself, prevent such recognition.
4. Child's Welfare Alone Cannot Justify Paternity Test: Karnataka High Court
The Karnataka High Court held that a paternity test cannot be ordered merely on the ground that it would serve the welfare of a child. The Court said family courts must record proper reasons before ordering such tests and follow the principles laid down by the Supreme Court. It remanded the matter to the family court for reconsideration. The ruling highlights the need to balance a child's welfare with privacy and the legal principles governing scientific tests in family disputes.
5. CCPA Imposes ?10 Lakh Penalty on Ola Over Extra Payment Feature
The Central Consumer Protection Authority imposed a ?10 lakh penalty on ANI Technologies, which operates Ola, over a feature that encouraged customers to pay extra in the hope of getting a ride faster. The authority found no evidence that the additional payment improved the chances of securing a ride, while the feature could pressure consumers to pay more. It also directed Ola to discontinue the practice, treating it as misleading to consumers.
6. Aadhaar Card Not Conclusive Proof of Age: Madhya Pradesh High Court
The Madhya Pradesh High Court held that an Aadhaar card cannot be treated as conclusive proof of a person's age. The Court observed that a postmortem report was a more reliable indicator while deciding an appeal concerning compensation awarded to the parents of a 13-year-old boy who died in a motor accident. The ruling highlights that the reliability of documents and evidence must be considered while determining age in compensation cases.
7. Accusing Wife of Adultery for Speaking to Male Friend Amounts to Cruelty: Jharkhand High Court
The Jharkhand High Court observed that accusing a wife of adultery merely because she speaks to a male friend amounts to mental cruelty. The Court described such allegations as based on gender stereotypes. The observation highlights that ordinary social interactions cannot, by themselves, be treated as evidence of infidelity and that making baseless allegations against a spouse can affect their dignity and mental well-being.
8. Karnataka Advocates Must Clear AIBE Within Two Years of Enrolment: State Bar Council
The Karnataka State Bar Council directed advocates who have not cleared the All India Bar Examination within two years of enrolment to stop practising before courts, tribunals and other authorities until they pass the examination. The direction was issued in compliance with a Karnataka High Court judgment requiring the Council to establish a mechanism to identify advocates who have not cleared the examination within the prescribed period. Advocates whose right to practise has been withdrawn can seek its restoration after clearing the AIBE.
9. Stamp Duty on Arbitral Awards Must Exclude Interest Component: Delhi High Court
The Delhi High Court held that stamp duty on an arbitral award must be calculated on the principal amount awarded and should not include the interest component. The Court observed that including interest in an arbitral award alone cannot increase stamp duty liability. The ruling clarifies how stamp duty should be calculated on arbitral awards and prevents the interest portion from increasing the duty payable.
10. Penal Action Against Peaceful Protests Would Be a Sad Day for Democracy: Bombay High Court
The Nagpur Bench of the Bombay High Court quashed criminal proceedings against a 26-year-old man booked for protesting poor road conditions in Chandrapur district. The Court observed that taking penal action against peaceful protests would be a sad day for democracy. The ruling highlights the importance of protecting peaceful public demonstrations and recognises that citizens must be able to raise concerns against authorities without facing unjustified criminal proceedings.
